Court of Appeals Upholds Trial Court’s Refusal to Enforce Illusory and Unenforceable Arbitration Clause

November 4, 2020 by

In late September, just 14 days following oral argument, a three-judge panel of the Dallas Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed a Collin County District Court’s ruling that a multi-level marketing company could not force one of its distributors into arbitration because the clause upon which it relied was illusory and unenforceable. In the lawsuit filed by one of its distributors, Travel to Freedom, WorldVentures Marketing sought to dismiss the suit and compel arbitration based on an arbitration clause contained in the 2020 version of its representative agreement and policies and procedures. However, despite its claims that Travel to Freedom electronically agreed to be bound by same by “clicking through” its website, WorldVentures could not prove Travel to Freedom ever agreed to be bound by this version.

To the contrary, the only evidence before the court to establish that Travel to Freedom ever agreed to any arbitration clause with WorldVentures was in 2012. And, as the Court held, the arbitration provision in the 2012 version of WorldVentures’ representative agreement and policies and procedures was markedly different from the 2019 version such that the 2012 version was illusory and unenforceable under well-established SCOTX precedent.

Founded in 2010, Brown Fox is a business boutique law firm focused on serving businesses, executives and entrepreneurs in practice areas most commonly needed to advance business growth, manage risk, and defend from attack. The firm’s representative clientele includes companies ranging from start-ups to publicly traded companies. The firm has offices in Dallas and Frisco.

Best Lawyers recently named Brown Fox a Tier 1 Best Law Firm for a third year in a row, Chambers & Partners has recognized the firm as a top small to midsize firm in both of its Regional Spotlights, and Inc. 5000 has twice recognized the firm as one of the Fastest Growing Private Companies in America. The firm’s attorneys have garnered over seventy Super Lawyers Rising Stars honors, several Best Lawyers honors from both D Magazine and Best Lawyers in America, among other honors.

Character Matters® is the firm’s foundational maxim; its core values of integrity, servant leadership, excellence, and impact are its roots. Brown Fox is committed to aggressively and creatively representing our clients, while staying true to the firm’s guiding principles. Learn more about Brown Fox by clicking here.

Integrity-Driven Advocates, Problem Solvers, and Counselors Ready to Serve.
Meet Brown Fox